Instagram’s Worst Con Artist
When Wellness Icons Sell Lies
I’ve been watching this fascinating series on The Search for Instagram’s Worst Con Artist, which unpacks the rise and fall of Belle Gibson—an influencer who built an empire on a lie. She claimed to have cured her terminal brain cancer through diet, alternative medicine, and holistic wellness, amassing a massive following and selling hope in its most seductive form.
But here’s the thing—she never had cancer.
Could one argue that some good came from it? Maybe. She introduced people to alternative approaches and lifestyle changes that might have genuinely improved their well-being. But at what cost? People abandoned proven treatments. They doubted their own experiences—Why don’t I look as healthy as she does? Why isn’t my healing journey as miraculous?
Lies don’t just mislead. They harm. They manipulate. They strip people of informed choice.
Gibson’s story is more than just a personal deception—it’s part of a larger pattern within wellness and New Age culture, where belief can blur into conspiracy. The Search for Instagram’s Worst Con Artist doesn’t just expose her fraud; it reveals how new age conspirituality taps into a deep distrust of institutions, particularly modern medicine. The wellness-to-conspiracy pipeline thrives on the idea that “mainstream” science is flawed, while nature, intuition, and personal experience hold the ultimate truth.
And there’s truth in some of it—modern medicine has its flaws. The healthcare system can feel (and is) impersonal, profit-driven, and dismissive of lived experience. People often do feel unheard by doctors, which makes alternative approaches deeply appealing. But the problem arises when this skepticism becomes outright rejection, when it turns into a black-and-white belief that only natural cures heal and only intuition knows best.
Healing is rarely simple. And it isn’t always within our control. That’s a difficult reality to sit with, which is why the promise of a clear, empowering solution is so enticing. But rejecting complexity in favor of easy answers doesn’t help—it creates more harm. It feeds false hope, breeds shame when healing doesn’t come, and makes people vulnerable to those who profit from their desperation.
Polarization isn’t helpful. A more integrated perspective is. Science and intuition, medicine and holistic wellness—these things don’t have to be at odds. We can honor personal experience while still valuing evidence. We can hold space for both caution and curiosity. Because real healing doesn’t come from extremes; it comes from balance, honesty, and the willingness to engage with uncertainty rather than escape it.
But that’s the problem. Because when healing is framed as a matter of mindset and energy, it inevitably leads to blame. The unspoken message? If you’re still sick, you must not be trying hard enough. Not enough love. Not enough green juice. Not enough visualization or mantras. The Search for Instagram’s Worst Con Artist lays bare the real consequences—people who stopped medical treatments, who clung to Gibson’s false promises, who believed that positivity and green juice alone could save them.
Fear, they say, is the enemy. But fear isn’t evil. Fear is wisdom. It’s a survival tool. In times of uncertainty, fear can guide us—if we listen, rather than suppress it under layers of spiritual bypassing. And yet, new age conspirituality demonizes fear while simultaneously weaponizing it, using it to sell products, programs, and ideologies. This is where wellness culture merges with conspiracy thinking: fear becomes the hook, and certainty—no matter how false—becomes the product.
And what’s worse? They monetize it.
Gibson didn’t just promote a lifestyle; she built a business off of it, selling hope in a way that left people even more vulnerable. And she’s not alone. The wellness industry is riddled with figures who leverage health anxiety, institutional distrust, and spiritual ideals to push their own brands, whether it’s anti-vax rhetoric, miracle cures, or an ideology that reframes suffering as a personal failing.
People wanted healing. They wanted hope. And that isn’t wrong. But they deserved better than deception disguised as empowerment.
Thanks for reading The REAL™ | GritandGrace! This post is public so feel free to share it. Share
We love to hear from you! Feel free to leave a comment. Leave a comment
Photo by Gilles Lambert on Unsplash