Ethical Persuasion vs. Propaganda
Why It Matters More Than Ever in Coaching, Wellness—and Politics
In today's world of curated content, charismatic influencers, and viral belief systems, persuasion is everywhere. If you're a coach, healer, or wellness practitioner, you're not just helping people—you're communicating ideas that shape how they see themselves, others, and the world.
And here's the uncomfortable truth: whether we realize it or not, we're all persuading.
The real question is—
Are we persuading ethically, or are we slipping into propaganda?
Before you recoil at the word, let's unpack it.
What Is Propaganda—Really?
Propaganda isn't just about wartime posters or authoritarian regimes. As media theorist Jacques Ellul1 explains in his seminal work Propaganda: The Formation of Men’s Attitudes, propaganda is any systematic effort to influence beliefs or actions in a way that bypasses critical thinking, simplifies complex issues, and discourages dissent. Rather than promoting dialogue, it seeks to shape perception and behavior through emotional appeal and repetition—often under the guise of information.
It's not always based on lies—it might even be technically true—but it's framed in a way that controls rather than informs.
In wellness and coaching spaces, propaganda can show up subtly:
Overpromising results ("This method will heal you completely.”)
Framing doubt as failure ("If you're not aligned, you're blocking your abundance.”)
Creating insiders and outsiders ("Doctors don't want you to know this.”)
But it's not just in coaching circles—it's everywhere. Especially in politics.
Ethical vs. Nonethical Persuasion: What's the Difference?
Ethical Persuasion Propaganda(Nonethical Persuasion)
Informs and empowers Manipulates and controls
Respects autonomy Bypasses critical thinking
Transparent intentions Hidden agendas
Encourages dialogue Suppresses dissent
Offers nuance Demands ideological conformity
In both coaching and politics, the difference lies in intent and method.
Ethical persuasion says: "Here's what I believe, and here's why. What do you think?"
Propaganda says: "If you don't agree, you're part of the problem."
When Wellness Meets Politics
The intersection of wellness culture and political ideology has become increasingly visible. From anti-vaccine narratives to conspiracy-laden "truth movements," the language of healing, empowerment, and awakening is often co-opted to push divisive political agendas.
What starts as a personal transformation journey can slide into echo chambers of:
Us vs. Them thinking
Mistrust of institutions
Absolute truths with no room for nuance
This is how propaganda thrives: it taps into real pain or disillusionment—but redirects it toward ideological conformity rather than critical engagement.
As practitioners and coaches, we need to ask:
Are we helping people think for themselves? Or are we—intentionally or not—nudging them toward dogma?
The Coaching Mirror: Why This Matters
If you're a coach, you're in the business of transformation. That's powerful. But with that power comes responsibility. In the wrong hands—or even with the best intentions but poor boundaries—persuasion can drift into coercion.
When we say:
"Your resistance is your ego talking—just trust the process,"
we may be invalidating a client's discernment.
When we say:
"They just don't get it because they're still asleep,"
we might be reinforcing the same black-and-white thinking we criticize in politics.
In polarized times, the coaching space becomes a microcosm of larger societal patterns. And our ethical commitment matters more than ever.
Leading With Integrity in a Polarized World
Whether you're guiding clients or engaging in political discourse, persuasion with integrity is the antidote to manipulation. That means:
Transparency: Be clear about your beliefs, methods, and limitations.
Critical Thinking: Encourage questioning—including of yourself.
Emotional Regulation: Don't leverage fear, guilt, or outrage to drive change.
Respect for Autonomy: Empower people to decide what's right for them.
This is the foundation of the REAL coaching model:
Recognize, Explore, Align, Lead—with ethics at the core.
The Bottom Line
In an era of mistrust, misinformation, and manipulation, ethical persuasion is radical. Whether you're guiding one client or speaking to thousands online, the way you share ideas has real power.
Let's trade manipulation for meaning.
Let's choose informed empowerment over performative enlightenment.
Let's keep it REAL—in wellness, in coaching, and in how we engage politically.
Thanks for reading The REAL™ | GritandGrace! This post is public so feel free to share it. Share
We love to hear from you! Feel free to leave a comment. Leave a comment